Skip to content

What Is the CAPE Ratio? Shiller PE and the Buffett Indicator

Module 7 · Step 7 of 16 · 7 min read

What is the CAPE ratio? Shiller PE and the Buffett Indicator

The CAPE ratio and the Buffett indicator both gauge how expensive U.S. stocks are against long run fundamentals, and both are poor guides to next year.

Written by the StockEducation Editorial Team · Reviewed by Associate Professor Charles Lo, CPA, PhD · Updated · How we check lessons

Quick answer

What do the CAPE ratio and the Buffett indicator tell you?

Both compare U.S. stock prices with long run fundamentals: CAPE with ten years of inflation adjusted earnings, the Buffett indicator with GDP. In 2026 both read near record highs, which points to lower long run returns, but neither says when prices will fall.

Key takeaways

  1. CAPE divides the S&P 500’s price by ten years of average earnings, adjusted for inflation.
  2. It stood near 41 in August 2026, against a long run average of about 17 since 1881.
  3. Its record was 44.2 in December 1999; its 1982 low was 6.6.
  4. High readings have come before weaker ten year returns, but in Campbell and Shiller’s 2001 study CAPE explained only about 30 to 40% of the variation.
  5. Over one year, short run noise in prices swamps the signal, so CAPE is a poor timing tool.
  6. The Buffett indicator was about 255% in mid 2026 on Fed and BEA data, and depends on what you count.

Start the lessonTake the quick checkRead the FAQSee the sources

Part 1 of 3 · The CAPE ratio

What is the CAPE ratio, and why ten years of earnings?

The CAPE ratio, or cyclically adjusted price to earnings ratio, divides the S&P 500’s price by its average annual earnings over the previous ten years, adjusted for inflation. It is often called the Shiller P/E, after the economist Robert Shiller, who publishes the data.1

Why ten years? Profits rise sharply in booms and collapse in recessions, so one year’s earnings can make the market look far cheaper or dearer than it is. Averaging a decade smooths those swings. Shiller and John Campbell popularized the measure, building on Benjamin Graham and David Dodd’s advice to judge earnings over several years.2

Worked example (hypothetical)

An index sits at 3,000 in a recession year when earnings drop to 60. Its trailing P/E is 3,000 ÷ 60 = 50, which looks wildly expensive. Its ten year average real earnings are 100, so its CAPE is 3,000 ÷ 100 = 30.

Same hypothetical index, two ratios

Hypothetical figures. Price 3,000 ÷ recession year earnings of 60 = 50; price 3,000 ÷ ten year average real earnings of 100 = 30. Notice how CAPE looks through the one bad year.

Read the full lesson on the CAPE ratio and the Buffett indicator for return bands and the calculators.

The rule

CAPE divides price by ten years of inflation adjusted earnings, so one recession or boom year cannot swing it the way it swings a trailing P/E.

Marks Part 1 done

Part 2 of 3 · History and limits

What does a high CAPE tell you?

In Shiller’s data, the S&P 500’s CAPE has averaged about 17 since 1881. Its highest monthly reading was 44.2 in December 1999, above the 32.6 of September 1929, and its 1982 low was 6.6. In August 2026 it read about 41.1

S&P 500 CAPE at key moments

Monthly readings from Shiller’s data. Notice how far August 2026 sits above the long run average, and how close it is to the 1999 record. Source: Robert Shiller, Online Data, Yale University.

S&P 500 CAPE ratio, 1907 to 2023, with the long run average

0×20×40×60×1929: 32.61982: 6.61999: 44.21920195019802010
December readings each year from Shiller's monthly data, plus September 2023, the last month with earnings in the file. The dashed line is the 1881 to 2023 average of about 17. The 1929 and 1999 peaks and the 1982 low are marked. The August 2026 reading of about 41 sits just below the 1999 record. Source: Robert Shiller, Online Data, Yale University.

Flip the ratio and you get an earnings yield: about 5.9% at a CAPE of 17, but about 2.4% at 41. Using the August 2026 reading above, you pay more than twice the historical average for each dollar of long run earnings.1

High readings have tended to come before weaker ten year returns. In Shiller’s data since 1881, months with a CAPE under 10 were followed by a median real return of about 11% a year over the next decade; months above 30 by about minus 1% a year.1

Median real return over the next ten years by starting CAPE, S&P 500, months from January 1881 to September 2013

−5%0%5%10%15%11%Under 107.9%10 to 156.2%15 to 204.7%20 to 255.2%25 to 30−1.1%Over 30
Our calculation from Shiller's monthly real price and real dividend series, dividends reinvested, annualized. Months per group: 227, 463, 514, 249, 83 and 57. Windows overlap, and the 30 or more group is mostly one episode around 2000. Source: Robert Shiller, Online Data, Yale University.

But in Campbell and Shiller’s 2001 study, valuation ratios explained only about 30 to 40% of the variation in those returns. Over one year, short run noise in prices swamps the signal, so CAPE is a poor timing tool.3 Markets can stay expensive for years, and accounting rules and the mix of companies have changed over 145 years.

The rule

Since 1881 a CAPE above 30 has been followed by a median real return of about minus 1% a year over the next decade, but it says almost nothing about the next year.

Marks Part 2 done

Part 3 of 3 · Market value to GDP

What is the Buffett indicator, and what does it count?

The Buffett indicator divides the market value of U.S. stocks by the size of the economy, usually measured by GDP. It is named after Warren Buffett, who has discussed it as a broad valuation gauge. Market value is a snapshot on one date, while GDP is output over a year.

Worked example

One government data proxy uses the Federal Reserve’s measure of nonfinancial corporate equities.4 With rounded teaching figures of $83.05 trillion of those equities and $32.49 trillion of annual GDP, the indicator is about 256%.5,6 With the September 30, 2026 GDP estimate of $32.56 trillion, it is about 255%.7

The Buffett indicator as a picture: equity value against one year of GDP, in trillions of dollars

Rounded teaching figures: Federal Reserve nonfinancial corporate equity of $83.05 trillion against annual GDP of $32.49 trillion, a ratio of about 256%. A broader numerator covering all listed shares would give a different number. Source: FRED, nonfinancial corporate equity and GDP.

That Fed series is narrower than the value of all listed U.S. shares, so two websites can show different readings with no change in prices.5 A percentage without its numerator, period and source is incomplete.

Quick check

Open Idea 4 of the full lesson and use its two fixed example models. Divide the example index price by ten year average real earnings, then divide equity value by annual GDP. Change one input at a time and record the numerator, denominator and result. Our P/E ratio lesson shows how to read a single company’s multiple.

Open the valuation calculation models

The rule

The Buffett indicator divides a one day snapshot of market value by a full year of output, and its reading depends on which shares are counted.

Marks Part 3 done

Quick check

Quick quiz: test what you just read

Pick an answer to see why it is right. 5 questions, no account needed.

0 of 5 answered

1. How is the CAPE ratio computed?

Answer: B.CAPE averages a decade of real earnings so one recession or boom year cannot swing the reading the way it swings a trailing P/E.

2. A hypothetical index trades at 3,000 with recession year earnings of 60 and ten year average real earnings of 100. What are its trailing P/E and CAPE?

Answer: A.3,000 divided by 60 is 50; 3,000 divided by 100 is 30. The averaging looks through the one bad year.

3. What was the highest monthly CAPE reading in Shiller's data?

Answer: B.The December 1999 peak of 44.2 came at the top of the dot com boom. August 2026 read about 41.

4. In the Shiller data since 1881, what was the median real ten year return after months when CAPE was 30 or more?

Answer: C.Starting valuations above 30 have been followed by a median real return of about minus 1% a year, from a small sample of 57 months mostly around 2000.

5. Why can two websites show different Buffett indicator readings on the same day?

Answer: B.The Fed's nonfinancial corporate equity series is narrower than the value of all listed shares, and GDP vintages get revised, so the definition must travel with the number.

Questions people ask

What is the CAPE ratio? Shiller PE and the Buffett Indicator FAQ

Does a high CAPE ratio mean a crash is coming?

Not on its own. A high reading suggests long run returns from today’s prices may be lower than average, not when or whether prices will fall. Over one year, short run noise swamps the signal.3

What is the difference between CAPE and a regular P/E ratio?

A trailing P/E divides price by the last twelve months of earnings, and a forward P/E uses analysts’ estimates for the year ahead. CAPE divides price by ten years of inflation adjusted earnings. CAPE is usually applied to a whole market, while ordinary P/E ratios are often used for single companies.

How should a long term investor use CAPE?

Use it as context for return assumptions, not as a trading clock. A high reading suggests testing your plan with lower expected returns as well as your starting assumption. A low reading is not a guarantee of gains either.

Why do Buffett indicator charts disagree?

They count different things: listed shares or broader equity estimates, with or without financial companies, against GDP for different periods. Government data are also revised after release. Check the definition and date behind any reading.6

Next steps

You finished this step.

Mark this step complete to save your place in the course.

Your progress saves to your account. You can come back to any step from the course map.

Your notes on one card, and what comes next
  1. Step 1 · DoneWhat is the CAPE ratio? Shiller PE and the Buffett Indicator
    See your notes on one card
    1. CAPE divides the S&P 500’s price by ten years of average earnings, adjusted for inflation.
    2. It stood near 41 in August 2026, against a long run average of about 17 since 1881.
    3. Its record was 44.2 in December 1999; its 1982 low was 6.6.
    4. High readings have come before weaker ten year returns, but in Campbell and Shiller’s 2001 study CAPE explained only about 30 to 40% of the variation.
    5. Over one year, short run noise in prices swamps the signal, so CAPE is a poor timing tool.
    6. The Buffett indicator was about 255% in mid 2026 on Fed and BEA data, and depends on what you count.
  2. 2
    Step 2 · NowMark this step complete

    Completing each step keeps your course map and progress up to date.

    Mark complete
  3. 3
    Step 3Continue the course
    The learning pathFree

    Learn the rest in the right order

    Ten modules of lessons, videos, tools and quizzes, ordered so each step builds on the last.

    Go to the next step

Want the full sequence? See the course outline →

Up nextPart 1 · What is the CAPE ratio, and why ten years of earnings?
Next ↓
AI Tutor Online
Ask Anything
AI
Hi! I’m your AI tutor for this lesson. Ask me anything about the content — I’m here to help you understand it deeply.

AI responses are for educational purposes. Always verify with official course materials.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

Sources and reference material

Primary sources and original reference material for the concepts discussed on this page.

References added 14 October 2026.

AI Tutor Online
Ask Anything
AI
Hi! I'm your AI tutor for this lesson. Ask me anything about the content — I'm here to help you understand it deeply.

AI responses are for educational purposes. Always verify with official course materials.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

Free beginner guide

New to Investing? Start With Our Free Guide

20 pages on the basics, 6 safe ways to use AI, and a 10 question quiz. Free in your inbox.

Free PDF in your inbox. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Learning Path IncludedEvery lesson in the right order, freeGet the Free Guide

AI Robot

Ask Our AI Stock
Learning Assistant

Get instant educational answers about
stocks, investing, and StockEducation.com.

Instant Answers Built With Learners

Educational support only. Not personal financial advice. AI responses may contain errors.

Powered by AI ●

The Ultimate Investing Starter Guide

Free Stock Market
Investing Guide

A beginner friendly guide that covers the essential lessons and concepts every new investor should understand.

Beginner Investing Guide Form

Inside You'll Learn

Stocks & How They Work
Valuation Basics
Compound Interest
Index Funds & Diversification
Warren Buffett Principles
AI Stock Research & More
20+ Pages
of Value
Instant
Download
100% Free
No Strings