Skip to content

Index Funds, ETFs and the S&P 500

Module 3 · Step 2 of 30 · 7 min read

Index funds, ETFs and the S&P 500

An index fund holds the stocks in a published list such as the S&P 500, and an ETF is a fund whose shares trade on an exchange during the day.

Written by the StockEducation Editorial Team · Reviewed by Associate Professor Charles Lo, CPA, PhD · Updated · How we check lessons

Key takeaways

What you will learn

  1. An index fund copies a published list of stocks; an ETF is a fund that trades on an exchange, and many ETFs are index funds.
  2. A committee picks S&P 500 members using rules on size, U.S. domicile, trading and GAAP profits, so it is not simply the 500 biggest firms.
  3. Weights follow float adjusted market value, so the largest companies move the index the most.
  4. Index mutual funds trade once a day at NAV; ETFs trade all day at market prices and typically pay out fewer capital gains.
  5. The expense ratio sits in the prospectus fee table as Total Annual Fund Operating Expenses and is charged every year on your whole balance.
  6. Over the 20 years to June 30, 2026, 92.61% of active large cap funds trailed the S&P 500 after fees.

Start the lessonTake the quick checkRead the FAQSee the sources

All 4 parts of this lesson

Part 1 of 4 · Index funds and ETFs

What is the difference between an index fund and an ETF?

An index fund seeks to track a specified index of stocks, bonds or other securities, subject to fees and tracking differences. The S&P 500 is one stock-index example.1 An ETF, or exchange traded fund, is a fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange all day. Many ETFs are index funds, so the two words describe different things: what the fund holds, and how you buy it.

Index mutual funds are bought and sold once a day at NAV, the net asset value per share calculated after the market closes. ETFs trade throughout the day at market prices, and because of how they are built they typically pay out fewer capital gains.2

Index mutual fund or index ETF: same holdings, different wrapper

Index mutual fund
Trades
Once a day
Price
NAV, set after the close
Bought
From the fund company or a broker
Capital gains paid out
More common
Index ETF
Trades
All day on an exchange
Price
Market price at that moment
Bought
Through a broker, like a stock
Capital gains paid out
Typically fewer
Both can track the same index and own the same stocks. The differences are about how you trade and how taxes reach you, not about what you own, and neither protects you when the index falls. Source: SEC Investor.gov: Characteristics of mutual funds and exchange traded funds.

Read the full lesson on index funds, ETFs and the S&P 500 for more detail.

The rule

Index describes what a fund holds; ETF describes how you buy it, and many funds are both.

Marks Part 1 done

Part 2 of 4 · Inside the S&P 500

How is the S&P 500 built?

The S&P 500 is not simply the 500 biggest U.S. companies. A committee at S&P Dow Jones Indices picks members using rules on size, U.S. domicile, trading activity and GAAP profits, so some large companies are left out.3

Each member is weighted by its float adjusted market value, the value of the shares available to the public. The largest companies therefore move the index the most.4

Worked example

Hypothetical toy index: three members, weighted by market value

60% Company A30% Company B10% Company C60/30/10
Company A is 60% of the index, B 30% and C 10%. Like the S&P 500, the index is weighted by market value, so the biggest member moves it the most.

In a toy index, Company A makes up 60% of the value, B 30% and C 10%. If one member rises 10% and the others stay flat, the index rises by that member’s weight times 10%.

Hypothetical toy index: how much a 10% rise moves the index

Each bar is the member’s weight times its 10% rise, with the other members flat: 60% × 10% = 6%, 30% × 10% = 3%, 10% × 10% = 1%. Notice the same move counts six times as much in the biggest member.

The same weighting works on the way down. Spreading money across hundreds of companies reduces the risk of any single failure, but not the risk of a market wide fall, and an S&P 500 fund falls with its index.1

The rule

S&P 500 members are chosen by a committee and weighted by float adjusted market value, so the biggest companies move the index most.

Marks Part 2 done

Part 3 of 4 · Fees and results

What does an index fund cost, and why does it matter?

The expense ratio is the yearly fee a fund charges, as a percentage of your investment. You find it in the prospectus fee table, on the line called Total Annual Fund Operating Expenses. It is charged every year on your whole balance, so small differences add up.

Average expense ratio of index equity ETFs, 2025, asset weighted0.14%
Active large cap funds that trailed the S&P 500 after fees, 20 years to June 30, 202692.61%

The first figure comes from the Investment Company Institute.5 The second comes from S&P Dow Jones Indices’ SPIVA research, which compares active funds with their benchmarks.6 An index fund aims to match its index minus costs, so it is not built to beat the market. Low costs are a large part of why it has often finished ahead of active funds over time.7

What the expense ratio costs each year on a $10,000 balance

Each bar is $10,000 times the expense ratio. 0.03% is the fee on some large S&P 500 ETFs, 0.14% the 2025 asset weighted average for index equity ETFs, and 1.00% a level some active funds charge. The fee is taken every year on the whole balance, so the gap compounds. Source: Investment Company Institute, fund fees in 2025.

Several large ETFs track the same S&P 500, among them Vanguard’s VOO, iShares’ IVV and SPDR’s SPY. Their fund pages list each one’s current expense ratio, so compare them line for line rather than assuming they cost the same.8,9,10

The rule

The expense ratio is charged every year on the whole balance, and most active large cap funds have trailed the S&P 500 after fees over 20 years.

Marks Part 3 done

Part 4 of 4 · ETF screener practice

Do two cheap funds own the same companies?

Quick check

  1. Narrow the list. Open the ETF screener and use the Country, Category Group and Category Name filters to show broad U.S. large company stock funds.
  2. Check the fees. Open two funds’ official issuer pages or fact sheets and find their current expense ratios. Compare each with 0.14%, the 2025 average for index equity ETFs, and with 0.05%.
  3. Compare holdings. Use the issuer pages to compare the two funds’ holdings as well as their fees. Do they own similar companies?

Open the ETF screener

Two fully overlapping funds of 50 stocks each give you 50 unique companies; two with no overlap give 100.

Two funds of 50 stocks each: how many companies do you really own?

Full overlap
Fund A
50 stocks
Fund B
The same 50
Unique companies
50
No overlap
Fund A
50 stocks
Fund B
50 different stocks
Unique companies
100
Counting holdings is only the first check. Weights, sectors, regions and shared risk factors still decide your real exposure.
The rule

Two funds that track similar indexes can own the same companies, so a second fund adds diversification only if its holdings differ.

Marks Part 4 done

Quick check

Quick quiz: test what you just read

Pick an answer to see why it is right. 5 questions, no account needed.

0 of 5 answered

1. What is the difference between an index fund and an ETF?

Answer: B.Many ETFs are index funds. An index mutual fund trades once a day at NAV; an ETF trades throughout the day at market prices.

2. In the toy index, Company A is 60% of the value and rises 10% while B and C stay flat. How much does the index rise?

Answer: B.Weight times move: 60% × 10% = 6%. The same 10% rise in Company C, at 10% weight, would add only 1%.

3. Is the S&P 500 simply the 500 largest U.S. companies?

Answer: B.Some large companies are left out because they fail a rule, and members are weighted by float adjusted market value once included.

4. Where in a prospectus do you find a fund’s expense ratio?

Answer: B.The fee table shows the yearly charge as a percentage of your investment. On $10,000, 0.14% is $14 a year, taken every year.

5. You own two S&P 500 index ETFs from different companies. How much more diversified are you than with one?

Answer: B.Two funds tracking the same index own the same stocks, so your unique holdings do not grow. Diversification comes from different holdings, not from a second ticker.

Questions people ask

Index funds, ETFs and the S&P 500 FAQ

Is the S&P 500 just the 500 biggest U.S. companies?

No. A committee selects members using rules on size, U.S. domicile, trading and GAAP profits, so some large companies are left out. Its weights follow float adjusted market value, so the largest companies move the index the most.

What is an expense ratio?

The annual fee a fund charges, shown as a percentage of your investment. It appears in the prospectus fee table as Total Annual Fund Operating Expenses and is charged every year on your whole balance. Index equity ETFs averaged 0.14% in 2025.

Do index funds beat actively managed funds?

Over long periods, most active large cap funds have trailed the S&P 500 after fees: 92.61% over the 20 years to June 30, 2026, by SPIVA’s count. An index fund aims to match its index minus costs, not to outperform it.

Can you lose money in an S&P 500 index fund?

Yes. The fund tracks the index, so when the index falls, the fund falls with it. Neither the mutual fund nor the ETF wrapper protects you from that.

Does owning several index funds make you more diversified?

Not necessarily. Two funds that track similar indexes can own many of the same companies: two fully overlapping funds of 50 stocks each give you 50 unique stocks, while two with no overlap give 100. Weights, sectors, regions and shared risk factors still decide your real exposure.

Next steps

You finished this step.

Mark this step complete to save your place in the course, then carry on with Roth IRA, 401(k) or Brokerage Account: Which Comes First?.

Your progress saves to your account. You can come back to any step from the course map.

Your notes on one card, and what comes next
  1. Step 1 · DoneIndex funds, ETFs and the S&P 500
    See your notes on one card
    1. An index fund copies a published list of stocks; an ETF is a fund that trades on an exchange, and many ETFs are index funds.
    2. A committee picks S&P 500 members using rules on size, U.S. domicile, trading and GAAP profits, so it is not simply the 500 biggest firms.
    3. Weights follow float adjusted market value, so the largest companies move the index the most.
    4. Index mutual funds trade once a day at NAV; ETFs trade all day at market prices and typically pay out fewer capital gains.
    5. The expense ratio sits in the prospectus fee table as Total Annual Fund Operating Expenses and is charged every year on your whole balance.
    6. Over the 20 years to June 30, 2026, 92.61% of active large cap funds trailed the S&P 500 after fees.
  2. 2
    Step 2 · NowMark this step complete

    Completing each step keeps your course map and progress up to date.

    Mark complete
  3. 3
    Step 3Continue with Roth IRA, 401(k) or Brokerage Account: Which Comes First?
    The learning pathFree

    Learn the rest in the right order

    Ten modules of lessons, videos, tools and quizzes, ordered so each step builds on the last.

    Go to the next step

Want the full sequence? See the course outline →

Up nextPart 1 · What is the difference between an index fund and an ETF?
Next ↓
AI Tutor Online
Ask Anything
AI
Hi! I’m your AI tutor for this lesson. Ask me anything about the content — I’m here to help you understand it deeply.

AI responses are for educational purposes. Always verify with official course materials.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

Sources and reference material

Primary sources and original reference material for the concepts discussed on this page.

References added 14 October 2026.

AI Tutor Online
Ask Anything
AI
Hi! I'm your AI tutor for this lesson. Ask me anything about the content — I'm here to help you understand it deeply.

AI responses are for educational purposes. Always verify with official course materials.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

Free beginner guide

New to Investing? Start With Our Free Guide

20 pages on the basics, 6 safe ways to use AI, and a 10 question quiz. Free in your inbox.

Free PDF in your inbox. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Learning Path IncludedEvery lesson in the right order, freeGet the Free Guide

AI Robot

Ask Our AI Stock
Learning Assistant

Get instant educational answers about
stocks, investing, and StockEducation.com.

Instant Answers Built With Learners

Educational support only. Not personal financial advice. AI responses may contain errors.

Powered by AI ●

The Ultimate Investing Starter Guide

Free Stock Market
Investing Guide

A beginner friendly guide that covers the essential lessons and concepts every new investor should understand.

Beginner Investing Guide Form

Inside You'll Learn

Stocks & How They Work
Valuation Basics
Compound Interest
Index Funds & Diversification
Warren Buffett Principles
AI Stock Research & More
20+ Pages
of Value
Instant
Download
100% Free
No Strings