Skip to content

Module 4 · Step 13 of 24 · 10 min read

Robert J. Shiller

Robert J. Shiller, a 2013 Nobel laureate in economics, showed that stock and home prices swing far more than their fundamentals and built the CAPE ratio to measure valuation.

Written by the StockEducation Editorial Team · Reviewed by Associate Professor Charles Lo, CPA, PhD · Updated · How we check lessons

Quick answer

Who is Robert Shiller?

Robert J. Shiller is a Yale economist and 2013 Nobel laureate who showed that stock and home prices swing far more than their fundamentals. He built the CAPE ratio, which compares prices with ten years of inflation adjusted earnings, and helped create the Case Shiller home price indexes. His work sets expectations for the next decade, not the next month.

Key takeaways

  1. The CAPE ratio compares stock prices with ten years of inflation adjusted earnings.
  2. High CAPE readings have been followed by weaker returns over the next decade, but they say little about the next year.
  3. Stock prices can swing far more than the dividends and earnings behind them.
  4. Bubbles feed on climbing prices, excited buyers and stories that spread from person to person.
  5. Home prices can fall hard: the national Case Shiller index dropped about 27% from 2006 to 2012.

Start the lessonTake the quick checkRead the FAQSee the sources

All 4 parts of this lesson

Part 1 of 4 · Prices and psychology

Who is Robert Shiller?

Robert J. Shiller is a Yale economist who shared the 2013 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences for research on asset prices.1 His central finding, published in 1981, is that stock and home prices swing far more than the dividends, earnings and rents behind them. Psychology and popular stories can push prices away from value, sometimes for years.

Real S&P prices versus real dividends since 1871 (January 1871 = 100, log scale)

1002005001,0002,0005,000Real priceReal dividends18711929196620002025

Real price Real dividends

Both series are from Shiller's data, adjusted for inflation and indexed to 100 in January 1871, plotted every second January. Dividends grow along a fairly steady path; prices swing far above and below it, which is the excess volatility Shiller measured in 1981. Source: Robert Shiller: Online Data (Yale University).

He gave investors three tools you will meet again: the CAPE ratio for stock valuations, the Case Shiller indexes for home prices, and an account of how bubbles feed on themselves, set out in books such as Irrational Exuberance.

Robert Shiller in eight dates

  1. 1981
    Excess volatilityAsks whether stock prices move too much to be justified by later dividends
  2. 1987
    Home price indexesPublishes repeat sales indexes for four cities with Karl Case
  3. 1988
    The CAPE paperStock Prices, Earnings and Expected Dividends, with John Campbell
  4. 1996
    Warns the FedTestifies with Campbell that valuations point to weak long run returns
  5. 2000
    Irrational ExuberancePublished with stock valuations near a record
  6. 2005
    Second editionAdds the housing market
  7. 2013
    Nobel PrizeShared with Eugene Fama and Lars Peter Hansen
  8. 2019
    Narrative EconomicsHow stories go viral and drive economic events
Dates from Shiller's Nobel biography and Yale curriculum vitae. Source: Nobel Prize: Robert J. Shiller, Biographical.

Read Robert J. Shiller’s investor page (opens in a new tab) →

The rule

Stock prices swing far more than the dividends and earnings behind them.

Marks Part 1 done

Part 2 of 4 · Valuation in context

What does the CAPE ratio tell you, and what can it not?

CAPE stands for cyclically adjusted price to earnings ratio, often called the Shiller P/E. It divides the market’s inflation adjusted price by the average of the past ten years of inflation adjusted earnings.2 Averaging a decade smooths out the swings of a single year: profits shrink in recessions and swell in booms, so a one year P/E can mislead.

Shiller’s monthly U.S. data reaches back to 1871, so today can be compared with 1929 or 2000 on the same basis.3 In his research with John Campbell, high readings were followed by weaker returns over the next decade, but said little about the next year.2

The CAPE ratio, January readings, 1881 to 2023

020406019292000: 43.8192118811929196620002023
Shiller's monthly data; the dashed line is the average of 17.4 over the whole period, computed from the same file. Peaks: 32.6 in September 1929, 43.8 in January 2000. Troughs: 5.1 in January 1921, 6.6 in July 1982. multpl.com's reading for September 2026 was 40.42, not shown because Shiller's earnings data in this file end in 2023. Source: Robert Shiller: Online Data (Yale University).

The September 2026 reading of 40.42 sits close to the January 2000 peak and well over twice the long run average of about 17.4

The S&P 500 CAPE ratio at four moments

September 2026 sits close to the 2000 peak and well over twice the long run average. After January 2000, CAPE fell by nearly half in three years. Source: Robert Shiller’s data via multpl.com, Shiller PE by month.

Record a reading properly

A CAPE number means little without its details. Write down the source, the observation month, the earnings window and the historical period you compare it with. Keep apart when the data was measured and when you read it.

Then write the limits next to it. The ratio gives no crash date, and an expensive market can stay expensive for years. Treat it as one piece of evidence alongside earnings, interest rates and your own time horizon.

The rule

A high CAPE has been followed by weaker ten year returns, but it has said little about the next year.

Marks Part 2 done

Part 3 of 4 · The feedback loop

How do bubbles form in Shiller’s account?

In his Nobel lecture, Shiller called a speculative bubble “a peculiar kind of fad or social epidemic that is regularly seen in speculative markets.”5 Rising prices draw in excited buyers, and stories explaining why prices must keep rising spread from person to person, attracting still more buyers.

The bubble feedback loop, as Shiller describes it

  1. Prices riseAn asset gains for a while, for any reason
  2. Gains make newsMedia, friends and coworkers notice
  3. New buyers arriveThey buy because the price climbed, not for what it earns
  4. A story explains itA narrative spreads to say why this time makes sense
  5. Prices rise againThe loop repeats until buyers run out
Each step feeds the next, which is why a bubble can run for years and then reverse sharply once prices stop climbing.

Because the buying depends on prices continuing to climb, the loop can reverse sharply. Shiller argued the same feedback inflated U.S. home prices, which many people saw as a safe store of value.

U.S. national home prices, 1987 to 2026 (January 2000 = 100)

0100200300400198720002006201220202026
January readings of the S&P Cotality Case Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index, not seasonally adjusted and before inflation. Notice the climb into 2006, the slide to 2012 and the record highs since. Source: FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis: CSUSHPINSA.

The national Case Shiller index, which he helped create, peaked at 184.6 in July 2006 and fell to 134.0 by February 2012, a drop of about 27% before inflation.6 The reversal took six years to play out. For a buyer who put 10% down at the peak, that fall wiped out the deposit and left the loan larger than the home.

A $300,000 home bought at the 2006 peak with 10% down, after a 27% fall (hypothetical)

−$100,000$0$100,000$200,000$300,000$400,000$300,000Home value2006−$81,00027% fall$219,000Home value2012−$270,000Mortgageowed−$51,000Owner’sequity
The home falls by $81,000 to $219,000 while the $270,000 mortgage is unchanged, so the owner's $30,000 is gone and the loan exceeds the home's value by about $51,000. Mortgage repayments are ignored.

Try the research exercise

Write a market story you keep hearing in one sentence. Pick one valuation series that could test part of it, such as CAPE or home prices against rents. Record the series definition, the observation date and any change in what the index contains. A valuation measure gives context without marking a turning point, and a convincing narrative is not a forecast.

The rule

A bubble feeds on its own price rises, so it can run for years and then reverse once buyers run out.

Marks Part 3 done

Part 4 of 4 · Return scenarios

How do you keep a valuation and a return assumption apart?

A high CAPE tempts people to plug a precise return into their plans. Keep the valuation observation and the return assumption apart, and label the assumption.

Worked example

Put $10,000 away for ten years with no additions or withdrawals and hypothetical annual compounding: $10,000 × (1 + r)10. At 4% you end with about $14,802; at 8%, about $21,589. The difference is about $6,787.

$10,000 after ten years at 4% and at 8% a year (hypothetical)

$0$10,000$20,000$30,000$14,8024% a year$21,5898% a year
$10,000 × 1.04^10 = $14,802; $10,000 × 1.08^10 = $21,589. The return you plan on, which valuation helps set, changes the result by almost half.

These are constant rate scenarios before fees, taxes and inflation. They are not forecasts derived from CAPE, and actual annual returns fluctuate and can be negative.

  1. Reproduce the two balances. Label the assumptions and what they leave out.
  2. Record one CAPE reading. Note its source, month, earnings window and comparison period.
  3. Write two limits. The ratio gives no crash date, and it promises neither return. Name the other evidence you would need.
  4. Write your decision rule. Complete the sentence “Before acting on an investing idea, I will ____,” and add one circumstance that would make you reconsider.

Use hypothetical figures or virtual money for this exercise.

The rule

Four points of assumed return, 4% against 8%, changes a ten year result on $10,000 by about $6,800.

Marks Part 4 done

Quick check

Quick quiz: test what you just read

Pick an answer to see why it is right. 5 questions, no account needed.

0 of 5 answered

1. What does the CAPE ratio divide the market's price by?

Answer: B.Averaging a decade of real earnings keeps one boom or recession year from distorting the reading.

2. What did Campbell and Shiller find high valuation ratios predicted?

Answer: B.Valuation is a guide to long run odds, not a timing tool. After their 1996 warning the real index rose 80% before the 2000 peak.

3. What is excess volatility?

Answer: A.Shiller's 1981 paper found real prices moved far more than a rational forecast of future dividends would.

4. How far did the national Case Shiller index fall from July 2006 to February 2012?

Answer: C.It fell from 184.6 to 134.0 before inflation, and prices fell across the country rather than in one region.

5. $10,000 is left for ten years with no additions, compounding once a year. What is the gap between a 4% and an 8% assumed return?

Answer: C.$10,000 × 1.04^10 is about $14,802 and $10,000 × 1.08^10 is about $21,589. A valuation reading helps shape which assumption is reasonable, but neither number is a forecast.

Questions people ask

Robert J. Shiller FAQ

What is the CAPE ratio?

It compares stock prices with the average of the past ten years of inflation adjusted earnings, which smooths out the swings of a single year’s profits.2 It is also called the Shiller P/E.

Can the CAPE ratio predict a market crash?

No. High readings have historically been followed by weaker returns over the next decade, but they have said little about the next year and give no crash date. Use it as context, not a timing signal.

Who is Robert Shiller?

A Yale economist who shared the 2013 Nobel Memorial Prize for research on asset prices.1 He is known for CAPE, for showing that stock prices swing far more than the dividends and earnings behind them, and for helping create the Case Shiller home price index.

Can home prices fall sharply?

Yes. The national Case Shiller index dropped about 27% from July 2006 to February 2012.6 Shiller argued that rising prices, excited buyers and spreading stories can inflate housing just as they inflate stocks.

Next steps

You finished this step.

Mark this step complete to save your place in the course, then carry on with Cathie Wood.

Your progress saves to your account. You can come back to any step from the course map.

Your notes on one card, and what comes next
  1. Step 1 · DoneRobert J. Shiller
    See your notes on one card
    1. The CAPE ratio compares stock prices with ten years of inflation adjusted earnings.
    2. High CAPE readings have been followed by weaker returns over the next decade, but they say little about the next year.
    3. Stock prices can swing far more than the dividends and earnings behind them.
    4. Bubbles feed on climbing prices, excited buyers and stories that spread from person to person.
    5. Home prices can fall hard: the national Case Shiller index dropped about 27% from 2006 to 2012.
  2. 2
    Step 2 · NowMark this step complete

    Completing each step keeps your course map and progress up to date.

    Mark complete
  3. 3
    Step 3Continue with Cathie Wood
    The learning pathFree

    Learn the rest in the right order

    Ten modules of lessons, videos, tools and quizzes, ordered so each step builds on the last.

    Go to the next step

Want the full sequence? See the course outline →

Up nextPart 1 · Who is Robert Shiller?
Next ↓
AI Tutor Online
Ask Anything
AI
Hi! I’m your AI tutor for this lesson. Ask me anything about the content — I’m here to help you understand it deeply.

AI responses are for educational purposes. Always verify with official course materials.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

Sources and reference material

Primary sources and original reference material for the concepts discussed on this page.

References added 14 October 2026.

AI Tutor Online
Ask Anything
AI
Hi! I'm your AI tutor for this lesson. Ask me anything about the content — I'm here to help you understand it deeply.

AI responses are for educational purposes. Always verify with official course materials.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

This lesson teaches a concept. It is general education, not advice about your money. Before you act on anything you learn here, speak to someone licensed.

Free beginner guide

New to Investing? Start With Our Free Guide

20 pages on the basics, 6 safe ways to use AI, and a 10 question quiz. Free in your inbox.

Free PDF in your inbox. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Learning Path IncludedEvery lesson in the right order, freeGet the Free Guide

AI Robot

Ask Our AI Stock
Learning Assistant

Get instant educational answers about
stocks, investing, and StockEducation.com.

Instant Answers Built With Learners

Educational support only. Not personal financial advice. AI responses may contain errors.

Powered by AI ●

The Ultimate Investing Starter Guide

Free Stock Market
Investing Guide

A beginner friendly guide that covers the essential lessons and concepts every new investor should understand.

Beginner Investing Guide Form

Inside You'll Learn

Stocks & How They Work
Valuation Basics
Compound Interest
Index Funds & Diversification
Warren Buffett Principles
AI Stock Research & More
20+ Pages
of Value
Instant
Download
100% Free
No Strings