How to Read Rule 605 Execution-Quality Reports

Read Rule 605 quoted and effective spreads, price improvement and speed for comparable orders. Aggregate statistics cannot establish an individual fill.

Akbar Shah portrait

Akbar Shah

Contributor, StockEducation.com · Editorial Standards

Edited by: Felix La Spina, Publisher

Published:  Last updated: 

This article is educational and does not constitute personalized financial advice. Verify all figures against primary sources before making decisions. Read our editorial standards. See how we fact-check.

How to Read Rule 605 Execution-Quality Reports

Publication check, 20 October 2026. The SEC’s April 2026 Rule 605 FAQs, 2024 amendments announcement and round-lot implementation notice were retrieved. The direct eCFR Rule 605 page was unavailable. The FAQs confirm August 2026 compliance and a separate November 2026 odd-lot benchmark requirement. No broker’s actual report or individual trade was audited.

Rule 605 requires covered market centers and larger brokers to publish monthly statistics for covered NMS stock orders. Compare quoted and effective spreads for like order groups, but do not treat an aggregate average as the outcome of one trade.

What Rule 605 requires

SEC Rule 605 of Regulation NMS requires covered reporting entities to publish monthly electronic reports on covered orders in NMS stocks. The amended rule added larger broker-dealers and specified other entities; it does not make every broker a Rule 605 reporter.

The statistics are standardized, which is the point — they are designed to be comparable across venues rather than merely disclosed by each.

The four numbers that matter

Quoted spread. The difference between the national best bid and offer at the time the order was received. It is a displayed benchmark, not the cost every order actually incurs.

Effective spread. For a buy, subtract the quote midpoint from the execution price and double the result. For a sell, subtract the execution price from the midpoint and double the result. A fill better than the midpoint gives a negative spread. Rule 605 reports a share-weighted average. The benchmark generally uses the national best bid and offer at order receipt. For midpoint-or-better limit orders, use the midpoint when the order first becomes executable.

Price improvement. The rate and average amount of executions at prices better than the national best bid or offer at receipt.

Execution speed. Time from receipt to execution, reported by order size and type.

Reading the relationship

The comparison that carries the information is effective spread against quoted spread.

For an illustrative marketable order against a fixed 1.2-cent quote, a 0.7-cent effective spread implies 0.25 cents per share of improvement against the relevant bid or offer: (1.2 minus 0.7) divided by two. Extending that subtraction to averages requires matching executions, benchmarks and weights; unrelated report averages cannot be combined as if they described one trade.

An average effective spread below the average quoted spread is consistent with net price improvement against the displayed quote for that reported group. Some constituent orders may still have executed outside the quote; use the report's dedicated improvement and outside-quote measures as well.

An average at or above the quoted spread does not imply that no order received improvement. The averages can conceal a mix of improved and worse-priced executions.

Price improvement and routing incentives

A market maker may execute a retail order inside the displayed quote. The report’s price-improvement measures describe covered outcomes; they do not establish why any particular firm offered that price. Claims about how informed a group is, or how competition caused its results, require separate evidence.

Payment for order flow and price improvement can coexist. Rule 605 execution statistics and Rule 606 routing disclosures provide different aggregate evidence and do not isolate a payment arrangement’s causal effect on a specific order.

The scale

The numbers are small per share and meaningful in aggregate.

A tenth of a cent of improvement on 100 shares is ten cents.

For a hypothetical $5,000 order consisting of 100 shares, ten cents is 0.002% of order value. Twelve identical orders would total $1.20; real order sizes and improvement vary.

The illustration does not establish what execution quality is worth to a particular investor. Spread, price, order size, volatility and trade frequency can change the amount substantially.

The dollar amount scales with shares traded. That arithmetic does not establish how a fund’s strategy performs.

Perspective matters. For a long-term investor trading infrequently, recurring fund fees may matter more than a small per-trade difference; for a frequent trader or an illiquid security, execution costs can be material. Compare costs using the intended holding period and order size.

The reform underway

Rule 605 was substantially amended, with compliance beginning 1 August 2026 and broker-dealers added to the expanded reporting framework alongside market centers.

The SEC’s 2024 amendments, with compliance beginning 1 August 2026, added summary reporting and expanded covered order categories and reporting entities. Comparisons still require matching security, order type, size and period. Related changes to quote definitions and pricing increments are covered in round lot sizes and tick sizes.

The April 2026 SEC FAQs set 1 November 2026 for collection of price-improvement statistics relative to the best available displayed price including applicable odd-lot information. That metric should not be assumed present in all October reports.

What the reports can be compared on

Location. Reports appear on market-center websites and broker regulatory-disclosure pages.

Effective versus quoted spread. Reports separate order-size bands because improvement rates can differ substantially between a 100-share and a 5,000-share order.

Order-type breakdown. Market orders and marketable limit orders have different economics from non-marketable limit orders.

Broker and venue reports together. Since the 1 August 2026 compliance date, a larger broker that meets Rule 605's reporting threshold may publish its own report in addition to venue reports. Rule 606 shows routing and payments; Rule 605 reports aggregate execution outcomes. Match covered orders and periods before comparing them.

Where this sits among your costs

The importance of execution quality depends on how often, how much and what the investor trades.

Contribution rate can dominate long-run wealth for a regular saver, but is not a substitute for measuring trading costs.

Fund expense ratios recur while a fund is held; their impact depends on the balance and holding period.

Spread and execution matter on each trade and can be much larger in illiquid securities. They cannot be ranked universally against other costs.

Compare the dollar impact of each cost under the investor's own assumptions. A per-trade figure and an annual fund expense ratio are not directly comparable without a trading frequency and holding period.

What the numbers look like in practice

Price improvement is reported in fractions of a cent, and converting it to something meaningful takes one step.

A tenth of a cent per share on a 100-share order is ten cents. On a 1,000-share order, one dollar. On a $50,000 position in a $50 stock, one dollar.

For twelve identical 100-share orders at the illustrative one-tenth-cent improvement, the total is $1.20. Different quotes or order sizes can produce a very different figure.

At ten million shares, one-tenth of a cent per share would equal $10,000. This arithmetic example is not a measured fund saving or a reason to dismiss a retail investor's execution costs.

What the four numbers look like together

A Rule 605 report resolves to four measurements, and their relationship is more informative than any one of them alone.

MeasureWhat it isIllustrative marketable order
Quoted spreadNBBO width when the order arrived1.2 cents
Effective spreadTwice the signed difference between execution price and midpoint, accounting for order side0.7 cents
Price improvement per shareHalf the difference between the two0.25 cents
Execution speedTime from receipt to executionMeasured in milliseconds

Effective spread is twice the signed difference from the midpoint, with the sign set by whether the order is a buy or a sell. In this example, the improvement per share is (1.2 − 0.7) ÷ 2 = 0.25 cents. That is $0.25 on 100 shares or $2.50 on 1,000 shares.

The quarter-cent figure is an illustration, not a typical result. The amended Rule 605 compliance date was 1 August 2026, and the expanded reporting set includes broker-dealers meeting the rule's 100,000-account threshold. Venue-level guidance written before that date may describe a different disclosure regime.

Before you act on this

This article explains how something works. It is general education, not advice about your situation. It does not consider your goals, income, tax position or how much risk you can afford.

Investing involves risk, including losing money. Before you act, speak to a licensed professional. You can check whether someone is licensed at Investor.gov and FINRA BrokerCheck.

Common questions

Does price improvement mean I beat the market?

It means you executed better than the displayed quote at the moment your order arrived. It is not a return.

Should I choose a broker on this?

It is one input alongside fees, available products and account features. Its importance depends on the securities, order sizes and trading frequency; this source review does not rank it for most investors.

Where is the national best bid and offer defined?

Regulation NMS Rule 600 defines the national best bid and offer, protected quotations and round lots as related but distinct concepts. The round-lot implementation notice specifies 3 November 2025 for price-tiered round lots. The SEC’s April 2026 Rule 605 FAQs separately specify 1 November 2026 for collecting statistics against the best available displayed price including applicable odd-lot information, with November reports due by the end of December. Match the metric and reporting period rather than treating all displayed-price benchmarks as identical.

Related reading: Rule 606 report explained · Market orders and limit orders · The order protection rule

Where to go next

Execution quality is one cost to evaluate alongside fees, spread and investment choices. Our orders and execution lesson explains the order mechanics.

Sources

Primary sources. SEC Rule 605 of Regulation NMS · SEC Rule 605 FAQ · SEC amendments announcement

Related research on this site. Related topic: payment for order flow, routing transparency and the limits of aggregate execution data.

Education, not advice. Rule 605 requirements are amended periodically; verify current requirements at sec.gov.

Additional source detail

SEC Rule 605 of Regulation NMS — order execution disclosure, including effective spread, quoted spread, price improvement and execution speed statistics. SEC Rule 606 — order routing disclosure. SEC Rule 600(b) — national best bid and offer, protected quotation and round lot definitions. SEC Rule 611 — order protection.

License. This may be reproduced with attribution to StockEducation.com and a link to this page.

A Stop Order Becomes a Market Order: Why the Fill Price Is Not Guaranteed

How to Read an SEC Suspension Order and Recognize Common Warning Signs

When a Broker Can Legally Refuse Your Order

When a Brokerage Account Is Escheated, What You Recover Depends on Which State Law Applies

You might also like

Free beginner guide

New to Investing? Start With Our Free Guide

20 pages on the basics, 6 safe ways to use AI, and a 10 question quiz. Free in your inbox.

Free PDF in your inbox. No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Learning Path IncludedEvery lesson in the right order, freeGet the Free Guide

AI Robot

Ask the
Stock AI Assistant

Get instant educational answers about
stocks, investing, and StockEducation.com.

Instant Answers Built With Learners

Educational support only. Not personal financial advice. AI responses may contain errors.

Powered by AI ●

The Ultimate Investing Starter Guide

Free Stock Market
Investing Guide

A beginner friendly guide that covers the essential lessons and concepts every new investor should understand.

Beginner Investing Guide Form

Inside You'll Learn

Stocks & How They Work
Valuation Basics
Compound Interest
Index Funds & Diversification
Warren Buffett Principles
AI Stock Research & More
20+ Pages
of Value
Instant
Download
100% Free
No Strings