Module 1 · 10 min read
Index funds, ETFs and the S&P 500
Understand what an index fund owns, how ETFs differ from mutual funds and why the expense ratio deserves a closer look.
Written by the StockEducation Editorial Team · Reviewed by Associate Professor Charles Lo, CPA, PhD · Updated · How we check lessons
What is the difference between an index fund and an ETF?
An index fund is defined by its strategy, copying a published list of stocks such as the S&P 500, while an ETF is defined by its structure, a fund whose shares trade on an exchange. Many ETFs are index funds. Index mutual funds trade once a day at net asset value, while ETFs trade all day at market prices. Either way, check the expense ratio.
Key takeaways
- An index fund copies a published list of stocks; an ETF is a fund that trades on an exchange, and many ETFs are index funds.
- A committee picks S&P 500 members using rules on size, U.S. domicile, trading and GAAP profits, so it is not simply the 500 biggest firms.
- Weights follow float adjusted market value, so the largest companies move the index the most.
- Index mutual funds trade once a day at NAV; ETFs trade all day at market prices and typically pay out fewer capital gains.
- The expense ratio sits in the prospectus fee table as Total Annual Fund Operating Expenses and is charged every year on your whole balance.
- Over the 20 years to June 30, 2026, 92.61% of active large cap funds trailed the S&P 500 after fees.
Start the lessonTake the quick checkRead the FAQSee the sources
Part 1 of 6 · Index weights
What does an S&P 500 index fund actually own?
An index is a published list of stocks used as a benchmark. An index fund is an investment that tries to copy it. You can’t buy the S&P 500 itself, but you can buy a fund that holds all its stocks, or a representative sample. The fund’s return will differ slightly from the index because of costs and small tracking differences.1
The S&P 500 doesn’t give every company an equal slice. It weights each one by float adjusted market value: the share price times the number of shares available to ordinary investors. So the biggest companies move the index the most.2
If A rises 10% and B and C do not move, this toy index rises 6% before costs.
How does a company get in? It first has to meet rules on U.S. domicile, an eligible listing, size, public float, trading volume and financial health. The profit test generally requires positive GAAP earnings in the latest quarter and a positive total over the last four quarters. Then a committee decides, weighing how well the index represents the market. Passing the rules doesn’t guarantee a place, so the index is not simply the 500 biggest companies.2 The dollar size thresholds change over time, so check the current methodology.
The S&P 500 weights each company by float adjusted market value, so the largest companies move it most.
Part 2 of 6 · Diversification
Does owning hundreds of stocks remove the risk?
No. An index fund carries the risks of the stocks it holds. When the market falls, the fund falls with it. Following an index removes the risk of a manager picking badly, but not the risk of the market itself.1
Broad also doesn’t mean equal. Because the largest companies carry the most weight, a handful of them can drive much of the index’s move. Read a fund’s top holdings and sector mix rather than assuming every company matters the same.
Owning more funds doesn’t automatically help either. Two funds that track the same index hold the same stocks, so a second one adds nothing. S&P builds its 500, MidCap 400 and SmallCap 600 indexes so that no company sits in more than one, which is why a fund on each gives genuinely different holdings.2
Unique stocks you own: same index twice versus two S&P indexes
So count holdings, not fund names. Check the underlying stocks, their weights, the index each fund follows and what it costs.
An index fund removes the risk of a bad stock picker, not the risk of the market itself.
Part 3 of 6 · Strategy versus wrapper
How is an ETF different from an index mutual fund?
“Index” describes the strategy. “ETF” describes the structure. An exchange traded fund, or ETF, is a fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange. Both ETFs and mutual funds can follow an index or be actively managed, so the ETF label alone tells you nothing about the holdings or the risks.3
The big practical difference is how you trade. A mutual fund order fills at the next net asset value (NAV), the value of the fund’s holdings per share, which is usually calculated once at the end of the business day. ETF shares trade throughout market hours at market prices, which can be slightly above or below NAV.3
Next calculated NAV
Submit an order; pricing usually follows the day’s close.
Market price
Trade on an exchange while the market is open.
Check the exact fund, share class and account before comparing costs.
Minimums and trading costs. Minimum investments depend on the fund and the broker. ETFs can carry a bid ask spread and sometimes a commission; mutual funds may charge transaction fees or sales loads. Read the actual terms.
Taxes. In a taxable account, many ETFs pay out fewer capital gains than similar mutual funds because of how their shares are created and redeemed. Inside an IRA or 401(k), that difference generally doesn’t matter. Your own situation may differ.3
Index describes the strategy and ETF describes the wrapper, and the two are independent.
Part 4 of 6 · Expense ratios
How much do fees really cost you?
The expense ratio is the yearly cost of running the fund, shown as a percentage of your balance and taken from the fund’s assets. You never see a bill, but you pay it every year on everything you hold. Find it in the prospectus fee table as Total Annual Fund Operating Expenses, for the exact share class you would buy.4
Three large ETFs track the same S&P 500 at different costs.5 6 7
Three S&P 500 ETFs: yearly cost on $10,000
A few dollars a year sounds trivial. Over decades it isn’t, because a fee taken every year also removes the growth that money would have earned.
Hypothetical: $10,000 over 30 years at three fee levels
0.03% fee 0.50% fee 1.00% fee
The expense ratio isn’t the whole bill. Add any sales load, account fee, commission or spread, and check whether a fee waiver is temporary and when it ends. Compare like with like too: two funds with different benchmarks need more than a fee comparison.4
A fee taken every year also removes the growth that money would have earned.
Part 5 of 6 · The evidence
Why do so many investors choose index funds?
Because most professional stock pickers fail to beat them over long periods. S&P Dow Jones Indices’ SPIVA scorecard compares active funds with their benchmarks.
Active large cap U.S. funds versus the S&P 500, 20 years to June 30, 2026
The report counts funds that merged or closed along the way, and it measures returns after fees but before sales loads.8 Results vary by category and period, and past results don’t tell you how any single fund will do. But higher costs are one reason active funds struggle: with the same returns before fees, the cheaper fund leaves you more.
Over the 20 years to June 30, 2026, about 93% of active large cap U.S. funds trailed the S&P 500.
Part 6 of 6 · Comparing funds
How do you compare two funds?
Change one assumption at a time. This calculator compares two hypothetical expense ratios on the same average balance. It estimates operating costs only, not returns.
- Find candidates. Use the ETF Screener to list broad U.S. large company funds that follow the same benchmark. Treat any fee cutoff as a research filter, not a quality guarantee.
- Read the documents. For each fund, record its exact index, share class, expense ratio, minimum and top holdings from current fund documents.
- Add a mutual fund. Compare with an index mutual fund on the same index where one exists.
- Check overlap and drag. Use the ETF Overlap and Fee Drag tool to see shared holdings and the long run cost of fees.
Two funds are comparable only when they follow the same benchmark.
Quick check
Quick quiz: test what you just read
Pick an answer to see why it is right. 5 questions, no account needed.
1. What mainly determines a stock’s weight in the S&P 500?
2. You hold an S&P 500 ETF and add a second S&P 500 ETF from another provider. How many different companies do you now own?
3. Which fund type can you trade on an exchange during market hours?
4. On a $10,000 average balance, what does a 0.05% annual expense ratio cost?
5. What did the SPIVA scorecard find for active large cap U.S. funds over the 20 years to June 30, 2026?
Questions people ask
Index funds, ETFs and the S&P 500 FAQ
How does a company get into the S&P 500?
It must meet rules on U.S. domicile, listing, size, float, trading and profits, including positive latest quarter earnings and a positive four quarter total. Then a committee decides, so it isn’t simply the 500 biggest companies.
Is the S&P 500 equal weighted?
No. It weights companies by float adjusted market value, so the biggest carry the most weight. Separate equal weight versions exist, but a standard S&P 500 fund follows market value.
What is an expense ratio?
A fund’s yearly operating cost as a percentage of your balance. On $10,000, 0.05% is about $5 a year and 0.64% about $64. Over decades the gap compounds.
Can you lose money in an index fund?
Yes. When the market it tracks falls, the fund falls too, and market wide losses can be large and last for years.
Are ETFs more tax efficient than mutual funds?
Often, in taxable accounts, because many ETFs distribute fewer capital gains. Inside IRAs and 401(k)s the difference generally doesn’t apply.
You finished this lesson.
You now have the main ideas from this lesson. Next, practice where mistakes cost nothing: a free account saves your progress and unlocks the practice simulator with virtual money.
Free, no card. Lessons stay free to read without an account.
Your notes on one card, and what comes next
- Step 1 · DoneIndex funds, ETFs and the S&P 500
See your notes on one card
- An index fund copies a published list of stocks; an ETF is a fund that trades on an exchange, and many ETFs are index funds.
- A committee picks S&P 500 members using rules on size, U.S. domicile, trading and GAAP profits, so it is not simply the 500 biggest firms.
- Weights follow float adjusted market value, so the largest companies move the index the most.
- Index mutual funds trade once a day at NAV; ETFs trade all day at market prices and typically pay out fewer capital gains.
- The expense ratio sits in the prospectus fee table as Total Annual Fund Operating Expenses and is charged every year on your whole balance.
- Over the 20 years to June 30, 2026, 92.61% of active large cap funds trailed the S&P 500 after fees.
- 2Step 2 · NowSave your progress with a free account
Keep your course progress and practice on real U.S. stocks with virtual cash.
Create your free account No card needed. Lessons stay free to read. - 3Step 3Follow the learning pathThe learning pathFree
Learn the rest in the right order
Ten modules of lessons, videos, tools and quizzes, ordered so each step builds on the last, from market basics to company analysis and risk.
Start the learning path
Want the full sequence? See the course outline →
Sources and assumptions
- SEC: Index Funds. Tracking methods, market risks and costs
- S&P U.S. Indices Methodology, July 2026. Eligibility, committee selection and float adjusted weighting; thresholds can change
- SEC: Characteristics of Mutual Funds and ETFs, April 2025. Structures, NAV, market trading and U.S. tax account context
- SEC: Mutual Fund and ETF Fees and Expenses, July 2025. Expense ratio definition, prospectus fee table and additional costs
- Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO) fund page
- iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV) fund page
- SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) fund page
- SPIVA U.S. Mid Year 2026. Report 1a: All Large Cap funds, 20 years ending June 30, 2026; historical category comparison and methodology
Sources checked October 16, 2026. Company weights and fee examples are hypothetical. The SPIVA statistic is dated, not a forecast. This lesson uses U.S. fund and account examples; local rules differ.
StockEducation provides general education, not personal financial, tax or legal advice. Companies and funds named here are teaching examples only. Nothing here recommends buying or selling any security. Investing involves risk, including the loss of money you invest.
